There’s No Substitute For Openness With Your Kids
I teach younger children. One school assignment is for kids to make a poster about themselves, answering a few questions such as when they were born and what their favorite things were. Every day, we have a few kids present their poster, explaining things they had on it and answering questions from the class.
Today, the girl presenting is a very sweet and smart child who has a tendency to be a bit precocious, as her parents are very open and honest with her, resulting in her knowing things most parents hide from kids.
Girl: “And when I grow up, I want to be a programmer and a surrogate!”
Almost immediately, a kid asks what a surrogate is, but I make them wait until after the girl’s presentation. When the presentation is over, plenty of hands go up for questions. I’m not surprised when the second student called on has this question:
Student #1: “What’s a serra-git?”
Girl: “A surrogate is someone who helps women who can’t get pregnant but really want to have a baby. She will be pregnant for them and then give them the baby when it’s born.”
[Student #1] blurts out without raising her hand again, sounding shocked:
Student #1: “You have to give away your babies?”
Girl: “It doesn’t have to be your baby. There are two kinds of surrogates. One type, it is your baby, but you promise to let the mom and dad have it, but the other type, the mom and dad make the baby with a doctor’s help, and then they just put it in you for the pregnancy. I’d do the one where it wasn’t my baby at first because it’s supposed to be easier. But I might do the one where it’s my baby, too, if the surrogate is open so I would still get to visit the baby but I wouldn’t be the mom.”
I’m torn on how to handle this. On the one hand, some parents will get angry if any topic remotely touching on sex, sexuality, or where babies come from is ever discussed in my classroom, even if I’m not the one discussing it, so I know I risk angry parents just from this answer. I know the best thing to do would probably be to stop taking questions now to avoid this topic getting any more dangerous.
That being said, I also personally believe parents try too hard to shelter their kids, and all the current research and child psychologists I’ve read seem to agree with me on that topic. I have always been frustrated that I couldn’t answer reasonable questions kids have out of concern for parents’ responses.
This little girl is the perfect example of that; I know her parents tell her everything and she clearly understands it, and still, she grew up well adjusted and kind. I don’t like the idea of shutting the girl down from giving sincere answers just because parents may complain, especially since only two questions have been asked, and the kids may notice she got fewer questions than most and wonder why. In the end, my own curiosity to see how she will answer future questions wins out, and I decide to let a few more questions go despite risking irate parents.
Student #2: “Can you be a programmer and a surrogate?”
Girl: “Yes. You can be pregnant while programming, but I might have to take a day off to have the baby.”
Student #3: “Why do you want to be a surrogate?”
Girl: “My parents had me using a surrogate. They couldn’t do the kind where the baby is made by the mom and dad, so I’m actually made of partly my dad and partly my surrogate; we call her Aunt [Surrogate], but she isn’t really my aunt. She visits me sometimes and is really fun to play with, and my mom and dad are always thanking her for helping them have me because they love me so much. She made my mom and dad really happy by helping, and I want to do that for other moms and dads. Also, some moms and dads will pay lots of money for one, so it could help pay for college or something if I needed money.”
Student #4: “How does the baby get in the surrogate?”
Now here is a truly dangerous question for me, and I immediately start trying to think of how to interrupt this answer delicately when the girl beats me to it.
Girl: “Umm… a doctor helps with the one kind, but that’s all I’m allowed to say. You’re supposed to ask your mom or dad.”
Thankful for the discretion of this girl and her parents, I took the out here and ended question time after this question. I thanked the girl for her lovely answers and we moved on to the next child.
I eventually learned that at least one child ended up asking their parents some awkward questions about how babies were made thanks to this discussion, though, luckily, I didn’t actually get any angry parents blaming me this time.
Personally, I thought the young girl had a wonderful plan for adulthood. She is clearly smart enough and gifted enough in math to be a programmer, and I sincerely hope she does get to be a surrogate when she’s old enough.