I’m a teacher, and this was the most ridiculous thing I’ve ever encountered.
A parent stopped me in the parking lot to confront me because I made her child cry. How did I make her child cry, you might ask? I “forced participation” by making every child answer to their own name in attendance.
Yeah. Her child supposedly broke down sobbing to Mommy, because he was told to say his name so I could take attendance.
Then she pulled out her phone; she had been recording our interaction from the beginning. She kept recording while telling me that her child “no longer participates in attendance culture.”
I thought I was somehow caught in a satire skit on YouTube, but it wasn’t satire.
She told me that forcing her son to say his name without permission was harmful and that I needed to create a silent attendance system. She ordered me, and I mean flat-out ordered me, to figure it out since I’m the professional. She said that regardless of what I did, she was going to escalate this matter to make sure I would no longer be able to force her poor, traumatized child to respond to attendance.
So she filed a complaint, but not with the vice principal; with someone higher.
I have taught for YEARS, and this is the first time I have ever gotten a complaint for taking attendance.
After that conversation, I just went back to my desk and sat there in total silence, trying to process what I had lived through.
I was BCC’d in an email from the school board. In much more professional language, the response to her complaint was as follows:
Email: “Ma’am, you’re perfectly within your rights to file a legitimate complaint on behalf of your son. However, I must also make it very clear that we will not be taking any more time on this, frankly frivolous, complaint about your child answering attendance. If your child fails to acknowledge attendance, they will be marked absent and given a zero or a failing grade for the day. If your child cannot handle participating in attendance, then your child can be excluded from all participation, and he can be made to sit and be silent while all the other children are included and have fun. If there’s concern that your child might have special needs to be addressed, please reach out to the school counselor. Otherwise, we will treat this matter as closed and will expect your son to participate in class like every other student is expected to.”
The funny thing is, after all this, the kid still showed up to class, answered attendance like all the other kids, and even asked what we were doing today. I guess he can still participate, despite the violent trauma of having to say his name on the very first day!
The school does have Special Ed, where children who have disabilities are given special accommodations, and the teacher is fully able to communicate even with nonverbal students who can’t say their name or speak well. That class is a bit noisier than most, but it’s because the kids excitedly shout out the answer to questions. Now that the subjects finally make sense, they’re happy to be part of the lesson.