Do Not Question Which That You Do Not Understand
Client: “My daughter has taken a college English course and she says that every instance of ‘that’ needs to be ‘which’ and the opposite in all instances in the book.”
Me: “Actually, they’re all correct as is, honoring the standard ‘that’ for restrictive and ‘which’ for non-restrictive. For example, it would properly be, ‘The dog that my aunt had, which was a mixed breed, was named [Dog].’ If one were to follow your directive above, it would incorrectly read, ‘The dog which my aunt had, that was a mixed breed, was named [Dog].'”
Client: “She took a college English course.”
Me: “With all due respect, I majored in it, plus I have thirty years of editing experience.”
Client: “I’m sure the rule has changed since you were in college. Maybe you should take a refresher to catch up on current rules.”
I billed for the hours I’d spent and gently ended my association with that (not which) project.