Maybe He Converted?

(I am in line at a local poultry place with a guy in front of me ordering.)

Cashier: “That will be $8.48, please.”

(The guy gives the cashier a credit card. The cashier looks at it.)

Cashier: “May I see your ID, please?”

(The guy hesitantly hands over his ID.)

Cashier: “Sir, is your name Mohammed [Last Name], or Jeff [Other Last Name]?”

(The cashier gave the credit card to the manager and not back to the customer.)