Client: “I want the color of the site background to be the same as the picture I just sent you.”
Me: “That’s the picture with the distressed brick wall with peeling paint and graffiti on it?”
Client: “Yes, that one. I want that color as the background.”
Me: “Do you mean you want me to make that brick wall the background graphic of the site?”
Client: “No, no, no. I mean just sample the color of the brick wall, and use that as the background color.”
Me: “…”
Client: “It’s simple: just use the color sampling whatchama thing in Photoshop, and then use that color.”
Me: “That’s not how it works. There are millions of pixels in that photo, each with a different color. The reason you like it is that all those colors together create a pleasing effect, but even if I average a small area, all you are going to get is some sort of brown or orange/yellow. It will never look like the actual brick wall.”
Client: “Just do the sampling and send me some of the colors. I’ll pick the best.”
A day passes, and I send him a few samples.
Client: “Those colors look nothing like the brick wall photo.”
Me: “That’s what I was trying to tell you. You cannot sample a color out of something as complex as a brick wall and get the same effect.”
Client: “You just don’t know how to do it properly. I’ll do it for you and send you the color.”
Another day passes, and then another. I know this client has Photoshop but has never learned it, so very likely, he is using Illustrator to do the job.
Client: “I couldn’t get a good color out of that picture. But I found another picture of a brick wall on [Stock Photo Site]. Use that. Maybe it’ll work better.”
Me: “…”
Eventually, he had to admit that I was right after all. We have been working together for over eight years; you’d think he’d trust my judgment and experience by now.