Playing It Fair And Square (Or Diamond)
This story reminded me of my short-lived baseball career as a kid.
In the vein of youngest kids, anything my older siblings did was cool, so when one of my brothers started playing baseball, I wanted to play too. This went well for a few years, until my dad noticed that a lot of the coaches were more concerned with winning than with helping kids play baseball. Poor players, like me, would get put in the least likely positions to have to do anything (my position was right field, and at the tender age range of eleven to thirteen, not a lot of stuff got hit to right field, so I was mostly bored).
My dad, despite a busy working schedule of over ten hours a day (including commute), decided that he didn’t like that. So, for the baseball season, when I turned fourteen, I got a new coach: my dad (and my friend’s dad; we were on the same team).
New policies were implemented. The batting order changed every game, so that everyone got a chance to be the first batter in the order. If someone wanted to play a position, like first base or shortstop, then they would practice that position for the week and get to play that position for a game. If they liked it, they got to stay there. If they didn’t, they could try something else.
The only exception was pitchers: if someone wanted to be a pitcher, they had to be able to get the ball over the plate consistently, so that the other team had a chance to actually hit (and also so that there was less danger of getting hit by a pitch).
I always wanted to be a catcher because the gear looked cool. I wasn’t a good catcher by any means; I fumbled about one in every twenty pitches, and I couldn’t throw all the way to second base. But I got to try it out, and I rotated between catcher, shortstop (my other favorite position, where I was better), and center field for the season.
My dad never showed favoritism. Sure, I was his son, but I didn’t get the first shot at anything; if it was someone else’s turn to play catcher for a game, then I had to abide by that.
The parents of the other players HATED it.
My dad relayed a story many years later about how he had to constantly fend off and deal with parents who were arguing with his plan for play. THEIR son was the best hitter and should be the first to hit! THEIR son was clearly the best first baseman and shouldn’t be forced to play in left field just so some inferior kid could try it out.
My dad handled them all the same way: by calmly explaining that the players are kids, that having fun is more important than winning, and that they should talk to their kids about it. If a parent threatened to pull their son from the team (and more than a few did), my dad didn’t bend or break; he just said that would be fine if that’s what the player wanted.
Not a single player was pulled.
And by the end of the season, our team just barely lost the league championship game to what was universally decided to be poor umpires (even the other team agreed that the umpires were terrible).
My family moved away from the area shortly after the end of that season, but my friend’s dad took over the head coach responsibilities and kept mostly the same policies in regards to player positions and play time. No one rode the bench; everyone played, and having fun was more important than winning.
And they won the championship the next year.
All because my dad took time out of his ridiculously busy schedule to make sure his son got a fair shake at playing baseball.
CORRECTION: Misspelling has been corrected.
