CONTENT WARNING: Pet Death (Prior to story)
This is the story of one of the most awkward Christmases I’ve ever been a part of.
[Boyfriend] and I always go to [Aunt] and [Uncle]’s house for Christmas with the rest of [Boyfriend]’s family. It’s usually a pretty good time; there’s a grand meal, conversations, fun stories, and lots of gifts.
The Christmas of this story was… not so great.
[Aunt] had three dogs, and one of them was very old and ill for a while and had sadly passed away several months before that Christmas.
Something I should mention is that [Aunt] is very dramatic. It’s not that someone shouldn’t be sad about losing a pet, but [Aunt] takes tragedy to another level. She is definitely a wallower. She cried and moped to every member of the family every day for months about losing her dog, bringing it up at every opportunity, and frankly, ruining a lot of special get-togethers by bringing it up. We all tried our best to comfort her even though we were growing weary of it.
Now, [Uncle] is the complete opposite of [Aunt]. He’s boisterous, giddy, and always the life of any group situation, cracking jokes, telling stories, and being positive.
Apparently, during this time, [Aunt] had told [Uncle] in her grief that she wanted to go dig up her departed dog just to cuddle him one more time. A little morbid, yes… but we all say and do strange things when we’re grieving. [Uncle] took this as an opportunity to get [Aunt] a thoughtful gift for Christmas. He had seen something online about this company that makes stuffed replicas of people’s deceased pets (not like a plush thing — slightly more lifelike), and apparently, they were quite expensive.
Just before the gift-giving on this particular Christmas, [Uncle] quietly told a few of us what he had gotten for [Aunt]. Our private reactions amongst ourselves were a collective “Uh-oh…”
While the thought was very sweet and meaningful and [Uncle]’s heart was in the right place… we all knew [Aunt] well enough to know this wouldn’t go down well.
Sadly, we were right.
[Aunt] happily tore into the gift from her husband, with all of us holding our breath and watching. When she pulled the stuffed replica of her deceased dog from the box… she immediately burst into tears and fled from the room.
You could have cut the silence in the living room with a knife. [Uncle] looked very embarrassed, disappointed, and hurt. We all knew he was just trying to do something sweet that he thought his wife would cherish. I’m not sure how all of us anticipated his gift backfiring like it did, and he somehow didn’t see it coming.
We offered [Uncle] words of encouragement and tried to reassure him that we knew he meant well and that [Aunt] would come around and see how thoughtful his gift was once she got over the initial shock.
To add insult to injury, when the time came for [Uncle] to open his gift from [Aunt] (she was still bawling her eyes out in the back bedroom), he sullenly tore the paper off the box to see what his wife had given him for Christmas.
Her gift to him was a single shaker of steak seasoning.
None of us can figure out why they’re still together since the rest of the family knows both of them better than they apparently know each other, but that’s not for us to judge. Suffice it to say, the family cleared out pretty quickly after the gifts, and last we heard, [Aunt] and [Uncle] didn’t speak to each other for an entire week after that Christmas.