A, E, I, O, U, And Sometimes There Is No Why
My aunt and uncle manage a rental property with several different lots and houses on them. They report to the actual owners, but most of the tenants go to them with any problems they have. My aunt also suffers from anxiety that’s ramping up, so I tend to hang out when her husband isn’t home under the guise of babysitting my cousins. Her anxiety knows they’re safe under my watch while she works, and I get paid and fed. It’s a pretty sweet gig.
One day, one of the tenants calls, upset. Someone has broken into the shed in her backyard and emptied it. My uncle goes to investigate, and my aunt calls the owners, as well as security. By the time my uncle gets back, the owners and the cops have arrived at the tenant’s house.
Uncle: “Yeah, it’s cleaned out. There was a lock on the front of it, but they used bolt cutters. We found the lock tossed aside.”
Aunt: “What? Why?”
Uncle: “She had some tools and stuff in there. There have been other break-ins in the area, but this is the first on our property. She was giving a statement to the cops when I left. Security left to get the tapes from last night.”
Me: “What did they take?”
Uncle: “She didn’t go in too far, but from what she could tell, she’s definitely missing some tools, her mower, and a bunch of supplies from her woodworking.”
Me: “That’s awful.”
Aunt: “But I don’t understand. Why would they do that?”
Uncle: “Who knows? But she was definitely robbed.”
Aunt: “But… why?“
Me: “Tools can be pretty valuable, and she’s kind of the handyman for her neighbors. I bet she had some high-end ones that will fetch a good price when sold. That sucks.”
Aunt: “But… I just don’t understand! Why? Why would someone do that?”
Uncle: “For money. For the thrill. Who knows? Remember when we had taggers? It was a bunch of kids doing it for laughs.”
Aunt: *Frustrated, nearly yelling* “But why would they do that? I don’t understand!“
Me: “They probably took them to sell them. Maybe they’ll be caught and we can ask them. Were the tools insured?”
Uncle: “She said some were, but some belonged to her late husband and were more sentimental than anything. She’s really upset about those.”
Me: “That’s awful.”
Aunt: *Yelling* “BUT WHY WOULD SOMEONE DO THAT?”
Uncle: “We don’t know yet, hon—”
Aunt: *Still yelling* “IT DOESN’T MAKE ANY SENSE!”
Uncle: “Honey, breathe. Here, drink some water. The cops and security are there with her, and no one was hurt.”
Aunt: *Angrily crying* “BUT WHY? WHY WOULD SOMEONE DO THAT?”
Me: “For money, probably. Here, let’s sit down—”
She swats at me and screams.
Aunt: “I don’t UNDERSTAND!”
Me: *Yells* “YOU’RE NOT SUPPOSED TO!”
My aunt falls silent.
Me: “I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have yelled. Here, drink this water, and take some deep breaths.”
Aunt: *Drinks* “I just don’t understand. I don’t understand. Why would someone do that? It doesn’t make any sense. Why would someone do that? Why?!“
Me: *Calmly* “Are you a thief?”
Aunt: “What? No! What?!”
Me: “Do you break into people’s homes to steal things?”
Aunt: “No!”
Me: “Then you wouldn’t understand why someone would break into a place to steal things, would you?”
Aunt: *Long pause* “Oh. I guess not.”
And she went back to work, much more calm and collected. I apologized again for yelling at her, but she waved me off and said her anxiety clearly needed to hear that.
Later, she told me she was embarrassed by her reaction; they’ve been managing that property for over fifteen years, and that wasn’t the first time they’d had to deal with a break-in, but it was the first time she’d reacted like that. The tenant, unfortunately, never got her items back, but my aunt swapped to a higher dose of anti-anxiety medication and is doing much better.