Scarlet With Phobic Fury Over Violet
I work for a small independent video game shop in the middle of the city. In addition to selling games new, we also do trade-ins and sell things secondhand. Normally, there’s only one person in the shop at once, but during the winter, we two-man the store just to avoid letting things get too crowded by holiday buyers. (The exception was during a certain recent health crisis, where we had other ways to enforce a non-crowded shop, but that’s a separate story.)
During the holiday season of 2023, I was on a shift with the shop’s owner. A man came in and bought Pokémon Violet for the Nintendo Switch as a holiday gift for his son. We explained to him in no uncertain terms that sales were final; if his son was dissatisfied with the game, he could trade it in for store credit or cash, but he couldn’t get a return. The man accepted this and made some small talk while we were checking him out.
In mid-January of 2024, just as the holiday crowds were thinning out, the man came back in with Pokémon Violet in hand and a look of outrage on his face. I was baffled when he started swearing at us for how “inappropriate” this game was. He didn’t want a refund; he wanted us to take every copy of Scarlet and Violet off our shelves and burn them. (Whether or not that would render a Nintendo cartridge unplayable is left as an exercise for someone braver than me.)
After a few minutes, we managed to get this man to explain what exactly he took issue with. I try not to remember his exact dialogue for the number of slurs he used, but he claimed there were several trans characters in the game with no attention drawn to them, treated as the gender they presented as with no remarks on it. Bigot he was, this apparently made the game “inappropriate for children” and deserving of being destroyed, regardless of what the CERO, PEGI, and ESRB judges had to say about it.
My boss called him out for his a**holery and banned him from the store.
Now, I own a copy of Pokémon Violet myself, and I have no idea what this guy was talking about. In fact, when I got home that day, I immediately started a new playthrough, paying a lot of attention to every character I could see to figure out where exactly this a**hole saw a trans character. My best guess is that this bigot saw the one somewhat-androgynous male character (and that’s mostly because he lives on a snowy mountain and bundles up for the weather) and just made assumptions.
I have no idea whether that was deliberate on the developers’ part, but I’m certainly not going to complain about the fact that this game weeds out the a**holes.
