You Can’t Pull The Cheese Over Our Eyes Anymore
I used to be a shift leader at a corporate pizza place. We had this customer who would constantly complain every time he ordered. He complained that we made his pizzas on the wrong crust or with the wrong toppings, that we gave him the wrong wings with the wrong sauce on them, and/or that we didn’t include his breadsticks. This went on for a long time until we caught on to what he was doing. My boss told him no more credits, no more refunds.
After that, we didn’t hear from him for months until one day, when he ordered carryout. The next day, he called to complain. That day, I was the manager on duty, and my server was the sweetest, most bubbly person you can imagine. Our customers LOVED her. We also had a visit from a higher-up, which comes into the story later.
The phone rang, and [Server] answered with a perfect customer service smile.
Server: “Thank you for calling [Pizza Place]. This is [Server]. Will this be for delivery or carryout?”
She listened for a moment, and the smile dropped from her face.
Server: “I’m so sorry to hear that. Let me hand you to my manager. Please hold.”
She very quickly filled me in, rattled off exactly what the customer had ordered, and told me that she had made his wings herself, had cut the pizza, and had also been the one to give him his order, so there was no way it was wrong. I believed her; she was a good employee and she didn’t make mistakes. I also had my suspicions that it was that customer, but I had to confirm it.
Me: “Thank you for holding. This is [My Name]; I’m the manager on duty. [Server] told me there was a problem with your order from last night? Can you tell me what happened, please?”
Customer: *With an attitude* “Yeah, I ordered [wings], but I got [other wings] instead, and it was the wrong sauce. The pizza was supposed to be a [premium crust] but it was a [cheaper crust], and it was supposed to come with three toppings, but it only came with one of them!”
I recognized his voice, but decided to make absolutely sure of it.
Me: “Thank you for bringing this to our attention. That’s definitely not what we strive for here at [Pizza Place]. Let me see what I can do. Can I get your phone number, please?”
He rattled it off, and I recognized it at this point.
Me: “Okay, so here’s the thing. I know who you are. And I know that our store manager told you the last time you complained that you wouldn’t get any more credits or refunds from us, so no, I’m not going to remake your food, I’m not giving you a credit, and I’m not refunding you.”
Customer: “Oh, you know who I am? I bet you’d know if I came up there and spat in your face!”
Me: “Sir, I wouldn’t recommend that, because that’s assault. And you should also know that this call is being recorded. Tonight, you are not getting anything from us. You can call in the morning and talk to my manager, but I guarantee you she’ll tell you the same thing I did. Pretty sure you’re done at this [Pizza Place], the same as you’re done at the [Pizza Place] at [Location]. I told you: I know who you are. Have a great night!”
And I hung up the phone. Just then, I remembered that the higher-up was there. And he was staring at me with his mouth wide open.
I filled him in on this customer, with the server and several others backing me up, not that I needed them; this higher-up knew me quite well as I’d been with the company for several years at this point and had gotten several recognitions for extraordinary customer service, including from the CEO’s wife, so I knew I was good.
And I was. He had no problem with what I’d done because that wasn’t a customer.
As far as I know, that “customer” has only attempted to order once since I left for greener pastures, and he was told absolutely not by the very same store manager. Good riddance to bad rubbish.