Earlier this year, I discovered an aggregating service for single trading cards. Unlike [Other Popular Site], this one would let you make one large purchase, they would have the sellers send the cards you ordered to their warehouse, and then you paid for shipping at the time that you asked the cards to be sent to you. Part of what made me want to sign up with [Service] was that if you requested $25 or more worth of cards sold through their [Special Program] to be sent to you at the same time, you could get free shipping. Since they came from third-party sellers worldwide, it could take a while for the cards to arrive, so waiting until your stash built up was worthwhile.
After my first successful purchase and shipment, I reviewed [Service] on a review site, saying that potential customers shouldn’t be scared off by the reviewers who complained that they had to pay for shipping because you could get your shipping free if you followed instructions.
Excited as I was to continue using them, I put off making another order until my financial situation stabilized enough to spend the money — about six months or so. When I finally put together a second order, I noticed that there was no way to get free shipping. I contacted customer service via email.
Representative: “That was just a summer promotion to draw in customers from the USA. We had banners all over the site for months.”
I pointed out that it would’ve been nice to hear about the promotion coming to an end via email blast for those who hadn’t visited the site in a while, and I thanked the representative for explaining.
Before I placed my order, however, I went back to [Review Site] to update my experience:
Review Update: “I have no problem paying for shipping this time, but this will be my last order with [Service].”
Cue a barrage of emails from [Service] saying how unfair I was for “picking on [them] because [they] couldn’t keep a promotion going that made [them] lose money,” that they were just a “small Italian company” that couldn’t afford to offer free shipping long-term, and so forth. At no point did I deviate from my refrain of, “That’s okay. I understand. I’m perfectly willing to pay for the shipping,” but they kept pelting me with emails — several over the course of an hour or two — repeating their sob story.
Finally, I broke down and wrote back.
Me: “This is starting to feel like harassment. As far as I’m concerned, we’re down to one of two options: either leave me alone and I’ll pay for my shipping and we can end our business relationship there, or you can refund me [amount I paid for the cards I have waiting] and I’ll delete my account on your site. But I’m not changing my review.”
They stopped pestering me — which I’m grateful for — but they also didn’t tell me their choice. After they’d been quiet for a few days, I tried to log in to finally pay for my shipping and discovered that I’d been banned.
But at least I got my refund!