Egg On Her Face
In the early 2000s, my wife and I had moved into a new condo and were excited to try out the diner directly across the street from the building. On the Saturday morning after moving in, we were tired of unpacking and decided to go there for breakfast. The food was pretty good, the coffee was decent, and the server was fine. All in all, not the best dining experience, but you couldn’t beat it for convenience.
Everything was fine until it was time to pay. The server dropped off the check, then disappeared. We waited about five minutes before I flagged down another server who was walking by. I asked:
Me: “Do you know where our server went? She dropped the check and hasn’t been back.”
Other Server: “Oh, she’s out back, taking a smoke break.”
Okay, a little weird and unprofessional to drop the check and then leave.
Me: “Could you cash us out?”
Other Server: “I can’t, but you can go to the register where the manager will take care of it.”
We did so, leaving a decent tip, and talked to the manager for a couple minutes, letting him know we had just moved in across the street and would love to come back.
We left, walked across the street, and were reading a historical marker in front of an old church when we heard someone yelling:
Voice: “Hey! Heeeyyyy!”
Turning around, we could see it was our original server, standing in the doorway of the diner. When she saw we were looking at her, she screamed:
Server: “You didn’t pay! Come back or I’m calling the cops!”
My wife and I looked at each other, then started walking over to her. When we got back to the diner, she had her arms folded and was tapping her foot angrily, looking like we were kids she had caught with hands in the cookie jar.
Me: “You dropped off the check and disappeared. We paid at the register when you didn’t come back after five minutes.”
She looked confused for a moment, then doubled down like a toddler.
Server: “No, you didn’t!”
To counter that stellar argument, my wife opened her purse and pulled out the receipt, with the tip marked. The server looked at it, glared at us, then stomped back into the restaurant without an apology.
Despite the convenient location, that experience was bad enough that we never went back to the diner. It closed about eight months later, and a great Chinese restaurant opened in its place, which we went to many times until we moved four years later.
