After recovering from a mild illness, I need to head out for groceries, but I’m still feeling a bit dehydrated. I head to an open, manned cash register, grab a couple of bottles of Gatorade out of the cooler, and approach the cashier.
Cashier: “Just these for you today?”
Me: “Well, so far. I’m a little bit dehydrated, so I’m going to pay for these now and drink them while I shop.”
Cashier: “Oh, that’s smart! Here’s your change and receipt. See you later, maybe!”
I thank her, grab a cart, and start shopping. I keep the receipt for my bottles of Gatorade in my pocket in case anyone stops me, but nobody seems to notice or care until I come across an employee stocking shelves. This employee sees me taking a drink of my Gatorade, immediately drops what he’s doing, and makes a beeline for me.
Employee: “Sir, you can’t drink that until after you pay for it! That’s theft.”
Me: “I already paid for it before I started doing any other shopping. Here’s my receipt right here.”
I start to pull the receipt from my pocket.
Employee: “I’m not falling for that one. Give me the Gatorade, leave your cart here, and leave the store!”
Me: “Could you call a manager for me? I think we’re having a big misunderstanding here.”
Employee: “I’m not misunderstanding anything. You’re stealing from [Store], I caught you, and now you need to leave. If I need to call anyone, it’s going to be the cops.”
Me: “You know what? If it’s that important to you, go ahead and call the cops. We’ll see what they have to say.”
The employee immediately starts to back down.
Employee: “Well… I…”
Me: “Please call your manager for me now, or I can go up to Customer Service and call for a manager there.”
The employee doesn’t respond, so I take my cart (with my bottles of Gatorade) up to the Customer Service desk and ask for a manager, who arrives a few minutes later. The employee has taken the opportunity to disappear.
Manager: “How can I help you, sir?”
Me: “There seemed to be a misunderstanding with one of your stock employees. I purchased a few bottles of Gatorade to drink while I shop. I have the receipt right here, and you could probably check with the cashier on register four or your security camera footage to verify it. Your employee saw me drinking one of the bottles, accused me of stealing it, and threatened to call the cops after I asked him to call for you to clear things up.”
Manager: “I see. Do you know which employee it was?”
Me: “I didn’t see a name, but…”
I give a physical description of the employee.
Manager: “Okay, I believe I know who you’re talking about. I’m sorry for the misunderstanding. You’re free to finish your shopping, sir. I’ll find my employee and have a word with him.”
I realize that paying for something before you shop to eat or drink while you shop probably isn’t all that common, but I have no clue why that employee was so intent on playing the hero for “stopping me from stealing”. I continued using that grocery store pretty regularly and never did see that particular employee again, so I have an educated guess on how his manager’s talk with him went.