If Any Of This Is Legal, It Shouldn’t Be
Back around 2007, I got laid off. It was not easy finding a job, but I did find one working as a sales associate for a small family-owned furniture store for $10 an hour plus commission. It didn’t sound bad. I was told my hours would be alternating Sundays on and off, Mondays off, and Tuesdays through Saturdays would be eight- to twelve-hour days. Training would take two weeks, and I’d be paid for it. I was told for training I would need to bring a notebook and a pen to take notes.
I was hired with three others. The training was basically watching videos and going around the sales floor learning about the furniture and different materials and woods.
I got my first paycheck and discovered that $25 had been deducted as a “training fee”. I talked to a lady who’d been training with me.
Me: “Do you have this ‘training fee’ on your paycheck, too?”
Coworker #1: “Yes, I do!”
Me: “Were you ever told about any training fees?”
Coworker #1: “Nope.”
I decided that since I needed a job and didn’t want to lose this one, I would just keep quiet.
When I got my next paycheck, I had the $25 training fee deducted from it again. On the last day of training, the new hires were all presented with business cards. When I got my last check from training, I noticed I had another $25 training fee deducted from my check as well as $25 deducted from my check for the business cards.
We were never told anything about any training fees or being charged for business cards. I should’ve questioned it, but I needed the job too badly.
Our manager told us that since we would be off on Mondays, we would need to schedule any doctor’s appointments or anything else for Mondays as we would not be able to take off when we were scheduled to work.
I had been there for about two months. My son’s school was going on a field trip, and parents were invited to go along. The field trip was on Monday, so I decided I wanted to go with him and went ahead and paid for the cost associated with the field trip.
However, the Saturday before the field trip, my manager told me and the other three new hires that he had a special trip he wanted to take us on. He said that it would be a tour of a manufacturing facility where they make the furniture. The trip was scheduled for that Monday — the same Monday as my son’s field trip.
My manager went over the itinerary and details of the trip.
- We would all meet at the store at eight o’clock and we would drive in our own vehicles to the manufacturing plant — a two-hour drive.
- He told us to get gas the night before because we would not be stopping anywhere; we would be driving straight to the plant.
- We would not be taking any lunch breaks, and we could not bring any food with us.
- We would be at the plant for at least six to eight hours.
- Once we were done, we would all drive straight back to our store and meet there around eight o’clock at night. Once we were all accounted for, we were all free to go home.
- We were not getting paid for this day, and we had to buy our own gas. We would not be reimbursed.
Me: “Hey, [Manager], my son has a field trip on Monday, and I planned to go. I’ve already paid for it.”
Manager: “No. This trip is mandatory.”
I talked to another sales associate who had been with the company a little longer, and he told me that most people quit right after this trip. He said they did this — scheduling these trips on our days off — at least two or three times a year. He also informed me that the company would deduct $25 from our paychecks as a “training fee” for this trip to this manufacturing plant.
Me: “Will I be in trouble if I don’t go?”
Coworker #2: “They won’t like it. But what can you do?”
I decided not to go on this mandatory trip, and I took my son on his field trip that we had already paid for.
The manager did say something to me about it, and I told him that I had already paid for the trip, so I had to go.
When I got my next paycheck, I saw a $25 training deduction on it. I went to talk to the payroll lady.
Me: “What is this deduction for?”
Payroll Lady: “It’s for the trip you all took to the manufacturing plant.”
Me: “I didn’t go.”
Payroll Lady: “I know, but we have to charge you the fee regardless of whether you went or not.”
I was mad, and I decided right then to walk out and never look back. The good news is that I got another job two weeks later, and that furniture store went out of business about two years later.