I’ve been working at my property for about five months, and it mainly caters to business travelers, so since 90% of our guests aren’t paying for their own rooms and usually have just gotten off a plane, I don’t have many noteworthy interactions.
The guest comes up to the desk, and I give the normal spiel, asking for photo ID and a form of payment. He hands me his card, and then holds up the work badge that has a picture of him, and is just labeled with a nickname and last name, one that is not very analogous to the name we have on his reservation. (For example, if someone was named Daniel Allen Smith and went by the nickname DJ, which is not his real name or nickname).
Me: “I will need to see a form of identification that has your full name on it.”
Guest: “That IS my name.” *Points at the “DJ” on the badge.*
Me: “I’m sorry, sir, but that name doesn’t match the one we have on file. I need to see a photo ID with a matching name on it.”
Guest: “That’s my photo, and there’s my name, use that!”
He points to the name on his card, which says DJ Smith, which is again, not the name we have on file.
Me: “Sir, neither name fits. I’ll need to see a driver’s license or something like that.”
Guest: “I’m not showing you my driver’s license; it has personal information I’m not willing to give out.”
I just blinked at him for a moment as he stared at me defiantly. I almost tell him that we have his address on file too, and I can easily just pull it up, but I don’t, maybe because I didn’t want to elicit more of his clearly rising anger. In hindsight, I wish I had.
Me: “I’m sorry, sir, but the name on your badge and card does not match the one we have on file. I need to see a valid photo ID with your full name on it.”
Guest: “No, you don’t, that is my name, and you don’t need to see anything else. I don’t give out my personal information.”
Me: “Without confirming that you have the same name as we have on your reservation, I won’t be able to check you in. I’m sorry, but your work badge just isn’t enough for me.”
At this point, my more experienced coworker, who has been listening, chimes in to back me up, telling the guest that we need it for security reasons, and we must confirm his full legal name.
The man just laughs incredulously, as if we’re absolutely insane, but gives in, I think, because he was starting to feel ganged up on.
Guest: “Fine, I know you don’t actually need to see it, but I’ll show you anyway. This is ridiculous.”
He pulls out his driver’s license and shows it to me, taking care to grip it tight with his fingers over the address. Thankfully, the ID has his full name on it and not his nickname, as I feared it might.
Me: “Thank you very much, sir, as my colleague said it’s for security reasons. We just want to make sure that only you can enter your room.”
Guest: “Yeah, like you couldn’t tell it was me, we’ll just have to agree to disagree.”
He says this while laughing, but is clearly red in the face from anger.
I proceed with the check-in as cordially as possible, and at the end, when I try to direct him to the elevators (which are not immediately intuitive to find at my property) he puts his hand up and interrupts me.
Guest: “Yeah, I’ve stayed before, I think I got it.”
He said this very sarcastically before storming off.
I looked at his stay history with our company, and see that he has stayed all over the country and leaves incredibly long, nitpicky reviews, so I made sure to let my manager know I’d be getting a negative survey in the near future.