Several years ago, I worked at a gas station with a car wash. This car wash used a chain that pulled every vehicle through at the same speed, about twenty-five feet apart. The car wash was the cause of about 80% of all customer grievances. This one was a bit different.
One weekday afternoon, I am stocking shelves when a young woman and an old man come in together. They spot me and say we need to have a conversation, so I move back behind the counter.
Me: *Smiling* “Okay, so what can I do for you?”
The woman is about to speak when the old man cuts her off.
Man: “Your car wash damaged my car! Both of ours.”
That’s not the first time I’ve heard this.
Me: “Huh. How so?”
Woman: “We were both in the car wash. I was ahead of him, and the car wash pulled his car into the back of mine, hard.”
Immediate red flag: that’s impossible. The chain can’t pull one vehicle faster or slower than another. I tell them exactly that.
Woman: “Is it po—”
Man: *Interrupting* “Are you calling me a liar?!“
The woman is visibly annoyed.
Me: “What I’m saying is that the car wash couldn’t have done this. Either you—” *makes eye contact with the woman* “—hit the brakes—” *looks at the man* “—or you hit the gas.”
Woman: “I didn’t touch the brakes.”
She sounds as though she’s started second-guessing herself.
Man: “I’m not stupid! I never touched the gas pedal!”
Now, not to be ageist, but old people are usually the ones who have issues with using the car wash, so he is my prime suspect.
Me: *Matter-of-factly* “Well, thankfully, the car wash is lined with cameras, so I’ll just go rewind the footage and see what happened.”
Man: “Oh, uh, that’s not necessary. We’ll just have [Company] pay for the damages.”
Me: “Well, [Company] is gonna wanna review the footage anyway, so I might as well do that now.”
Man: *Nervously* “No, no, let’s not waste any more of our time.”
I exaggeratedly raise an eyebrow at him and then glance over at the woman. She clues in that I’m laying the pressure on him and also looks at him suspiciously. Now it’s time to twist the knife.
Me: “Oh, but surely the camera footage will prove your Innocence, sir?”
Silence. Yep, it’s him.
I review the footage and, sure enough, while the man was being pulled by the chain at first, he hit the gas and rear-ended the woman.
I come back behind the counter and look at the woman.
Me: “Well, turns out he hit the gas and rear-ended you. Now, even though it happened in the car wash, it wasn’t caused by the car wash, so this matter will have to be solved between the two of you. If you would like the camera footage to provide to insurance, I’d be happy to give it to you.”
I looked over at the old man with a smirk. He clearly died a little on the inside, knowing he was screwed.
The woman thanked me and looked over at the man as if to say, “Pay up, sucker.”