It’s a pretty busy night, especially for pizzas. It’s clear to customers ordering at the counter that we have our hands full. Two women come in with two kids: a young boy and a girl. They order two specialty pizzas and only those two pizzas. They say they will be dining in, and the kids are commenting about how hungry they are.
Me: “It will be just a bit of a wait, but we will bring the pizzas out as soon as they’re ready.”
The women sit within eyesight of our pizza maker and the oven. They can see the cooks and the pizzas coming in and out of the oven.
Again, it’s a pretty hectic night and it isn’t hard to overlook something and make a small mistake. Our pizza maker misreads their ticket for their order and thinks it’s to-go, so he has two pizza boxes open and ready to put them in. He takes them out of the oven, slides them each into a box, and puts them on top of the oven.
WITHIN THIRTY SECONDS of this happening, one of the women approaches the counter and gets the pizza guy’s attention.
Customer #1: “This is my ticket number. Are those our pizzas?”
Pizza Maker: “My sincerest apologies. I’ll bring those right out.”
Customer #1: “Okay, that’s fine.”
She sits back down. The pizza maker gets out two stands and trays and put the pizzas on them, still piping hot and delicious and melty. Even my mouth is watering. Another server and I carry both pizzas out and set them on their table, and the kids are so excited that the food is there and reach out for it.
The other lady pushes their hands back.
Customer #2: *To the children* “Wait.”
I watch her sit there and poke the pizza with her fingers.
Me: “Is everything okay?”
Customer #2: *In the b****iest tone* “Um, yeah… we’re not going to eat these.”
Me: “May I ask why?”
Customer #2: “Because they’re going to taste like box now.”
I can’t believe it. I ask her to clarify what’s wrong because I can’t really comprehend that she’s actually saying this.
Customer #2: “The pizzas are both going to taste like cardboard because they’ve been in a box.”
They were not even in the boxes for thirty seconds. She didn’t even bother to taste them. The kids started crying and asking her to keep them, but she demanded that I take them back and remake them. I had to grit my teeth and bring them back, and they made those kids wait another twenty minutes for the pizzas because by that time, there were even more pizza orders our pizza guy had to get to.
I couldn’t believe how snooty they were. Hundreds of pizzas are made to go daily and picked up in boxes and enjoyed at home. How could you possibly believe being in one for not even a minute destroys it?