Reading some of the stories on here about teachers who can’t tell their heads from their a**es sometimes and dole out ridiculous punishments for the tiniest infractions reminded me of something that happened back when I was just a little five-year-old with undiagnosed autism in first grade.
My teacher was, to put it bluntly, terrible. She punished the whole class for something one or two students would do and had ridiculous expectations. I have two stories about her; the first is just her being petty, and the second is just cruel to an impressionable kid.
For the first incident, I had accidentally hit a girl in the nose. I don’t remember how; I think I was turning around and my hand was raised a bit, and I nailed her on the nose. Didn’t break anything, no nosebleed, I apologized, and she was fine with it. [Teacher], however, demanded that I write her an apology letter explaining “why” I had hit her. I hadn’t done it on purpose, but whatever.
At that point in my life, I had started to develop my handwriting style. Some letters I wrote a little differently because my parents taught me cursive when I was four and I liked how some of the letters looked. Most notable was my lowercase “a”, which I wrote as one would do normally nowadays — a loop and then a tail without lifting the pencil.
I hadn’t even written more than one word; I had written “Dea” out of “Dear [Classmate]”. Immediately, [Teacher] snatched the pencil out of my hand, erased what I’d written, and told me to do it again. She didn’t specify what I had done wrong. I just wrote it again, and she snatched the pencil from me again. She refused to tell me what I was doing wrong, just screeching at me, “DO IT RIGHT!”
Just a reminder. I’m autistic. Screeching like that without actually explaining anything does not help a five-year-old who doesn’t understand why you’re screeching at them; all it does is confuse them and lead them into a meltdown.
Eventually, I broke down sobbing and asked what I was doing wrong. She said I was writing a “cursive” letter and no one could read cursive yet.
It was one. Single. Letter. That anyone could have read. But, apparently, that warranted her screeching at me for fifteen minutes that could have been spent learning something new or interesting — not learning that my non-conforming handwriting was a blight on her sensibilities.
I don’t even remember if I finished the letter, but I do know that my dad was not particularly happy to find out that his kid had gotten screamed at for a single letter. This, unfortunately, was not the only time [Teacher] singled me out.
For a bit of context for the next story, our cafeteria was set up where each class had to sit at a designated table (imagine a picnic table but about eighteen feet long), and each table had to be called one by one to go get their food; if you brought your own food, you weren’t allowed to eat until the rest of your class got back to the table. You couldn’t sit wherever you wanted; if you had a friend in a different class, too bad, so sad. Designated seats only. This was a public school, mind you, not some prestigious academy.
One day, [Teacher] gave us detention and made us sit in the cafeteria after school. Not just whoever was causing trouble — the whole class got detention. She didn’t care if we were just sitting there minding our own business; if one person acted up, the whole class was punished. I was one of the ones who did absolutely nothing to warrant detention, and I don’t even remember what had happened to cause it in the first place. I just remember that I was sitting there crying my eyes out because I had recently read the first of the Junie B. Jones books and remembered when Junie B. got locked inside her school and couldn’t get out.
About ten minutes into detention, my dad came in. I lived a few streets away, so my dad would come pick me up and walk me home. My dad was confused and about to get pretty mad — why was I in detention?
What [Teacher] didn’t count on was the fact that my dad had attended this school when he was a kid, and the teacher who was watching us had not only been his teacher, but he had been her favorite student. She remembered him and, when my dad asked what was going on and why I was in detention, she vouched for me and said that I hadn’t done anything wrong. (She even said I reminded her of him, just doing my work and minding my business.) She let me leave since my dad was here to pick me up, she wished me a good day, and that was that.
The next day, I found out that [Teacher] was decidedly not too happy that I had left without her explicit permission. (Keep in mind that this woman wasn’t even watching us, and even if she had been, she couldn’t exactly stop my dad from coming to get me if I had done nothing wrong.) I don’t know how long the rest of the kids were stuck in detention, but I have a feeling a lot of parents weren’t happy.
When lunch rolled around, I got ready to sit in my usual spot. However, [Teacher] wrenched me up by the arm and marched me over to a single, unoccupied table away from all the other classes and told me I wasn’t allowed to sit anywhere else. I was forbidden from talking to anyone, and anyone who was caught sitting with me would get detention again. She glared daggers at me, and I imagine she’d hoped that since I was sitting alone, the lunch monitor would forget I was there and not call on my “table” so I wouldn’t be able to eat lunch.
I was scared and sobbing once again. I didn’t understand why this teacher seemed to hate me so much, only that she did. (Looking back at my school photo, though, I may have a hunch… Let’s just say I looked “different” from both her and the rest of my class.)
The next day, I tried to sit with my class. [Teacher] dragged me back to that same empty table and told me this was my seat from now on, and I would get detention if I tried to sit elsewhere.
Thankfully, this story does have a silver lining and happy ending that [Teacher] didn’t count on. My three best friends — two in my class and one in the next-door class — all effectively said “screw that”, and after they got their lunches, they came and sat with me. [Teacher] tried to get all of them punished and put them in detention — even the one who wasn’t in her class — and the lunch monitor reamed her out for isolating a kid who hadn’t done anything to her. Take a guess who the lunch monitor that day was.
From then until the day we graduated from fifth grade, that table became our spot. The four of us would sit at that table and enjoy our lunches because the lunch monitors and the other teachers all knew we weren’t getting into anything; we were just kids talking and being kids. I don’t remember if [Teacher] was there when I moved on to second grade, but frankly, I couldn’t care less.